Case for Apple Pencil Sleeve 2nd Generation Cover for Apple Pencil 2 Case Silicone Magnetic Skin for for Apple Pencil iPencil Compatible with iPad Pro Red

Yep main concern is if it would still magnetically still attach to the side of my 12.9"? And was surprised that indeed still stuck and charged. Tho at a much reduced attach force. Much easier to knock off the side now. But have a ESR Rebound case that has a flap that protects from that scenario.Biggest gripe it's a Bear to get on. Felt like being a fat man trying to squeeze into a scuba wet suit! :-)And would like it to be thinner on the magnet side to increase magnetic grip to the ipad.Beyond that would recommend as gives firmer grip less likely for pen to fly out of my hand due to it's slippery nature. And reduced my hand cramps during extend use.

The media could not be loaded.  It was difficult to get it onto my Apple Pencil.. But once i finally got it, i found that it looks and feels pretty good. I was worried that it wouldn’t magnetically attach to my iPad to charge, due to the thickness of the silicone pencil sleeve, but to my surprise it does magnetically stick. Though, it’s not a strong hold and will get knocked off fairly easily. The i unfortunate side is that it does not CHARGE my pencil.. i have to take the sleeve off in order to do so. Which is a pain, and it’s why I’m only giving this review 3 stars.. so if you’re looking for an Apple Pencil sleeve that’s comfy and ALSO still charges while in the sleeve, this product isn’t for you.. I’m not sure of any other products that hold up to these expectations, but i will keep looking and hope to find one 😕

EDITED: Will not charge through a case. It will charge if you take the ipad out of the case oe have a case that allows you to directly place the pencil with the case onto it with any other barrier. If you need the case to allow for charging with a case on , do not buy this product. If you do not mind taking the case off, which is super hard, every time you need to charge it, then this product is okay. It will protect your pencil and does provide good grip. So it does it's intended job.

Hard to take off sleeve but doesn’t slide off or move around when using the holder so that’s a plus.

Cute, comfortable and protects the i pencil.

Love the color, it looks really good and is comfortable to hold. However, the silicon is really thin. After a bit the top ripped by the charge port area.

I love it , the only thing I dont like is with the sleeve on my pen it does not fit in theipad case that has a spot for the apple pen

Comfortable enough. I thought that the texture around the grippy part would help keep my thumb oriented a bit better for the double-tap to switch features. It helps some, but not as much as I expected. Still clings to my iPad with the magnet as it’s supposed to, so doesn’t interfere there. Easy to get on, but not very easy to get off once it is on. I tried to remove it to get the pencil to fit into a case that I have that has a holder built in, and it was a bit of a struggle. So, if you have a case that has a set in spot to hold your pencil, this might interfere with that. I found I could mush it in a bit, and it would charge... but it didn’t hold the position very reliably.